Keelefilosoofia raamat
But the only plausible general analysis of truth is in terms of
stating or asserting things: "One who makes a statement or assertion makes
a true statement if and only if things are as, in making that statement, he
states them to be" (Strawson 1970: 15). Which is to say that the analysis must
be made in terms of communication, which must be cashed à la Grice. Thus,
although the letter of truth-conditional semantics may be unobjectionable,
its spirit is broken, for it collapses into Griceanism rather than standing as a
superior alternative.
First reply
Whether or not we have an accepted general philosophical analysis of truth,
we have the concept expressed by the ordinary English word "true," and
we also have the formal structure introduced by Tarski, which generates
T-sentences. If the notion of meaning can be reduced to that of truth, that is
Truth-Condition Theories: Davidson's program 123