Keelefilosoofia raamat
therefore synonymous. This Proposition Theory fits the various "meaning
facts" well, since "proposition" is essentially another word for "meaning."
But critics have questioned whether it explains the meaning facts satisfacto-
rily, or indeed at all.
When this book began, the topics of reference and meaning were not sepa-
rate, because the most common naive idea people have about meaning is that
meaning is reference. In chapter 1 we disparaged the commonsensical but
untenable Referential Theory of Meaning. So we must now confront mean-
ing directly, and look at some more sophisticated theories of meaning.
Like any theory, a theory of meaning has to have a proprietary set of data.
What are the primary data for a theory of meaning? I will refer to them cor-
porately as "the meaning facts."
First, as we emphasized in chapter 1, there is meaningfulness itself. Some